Over the past two years, filming behind the scenes at the Top Technician, Top Garage and Top Apprentice finals has offered a side to the independent aftermarket that you rarely see from the stage or on a trophy engraving. And yet, almost all will be able to relate.
When you put technicians, apprentices and business owners in front of a camera and give them space to talk honestly, the initial nerves fade and the bravado drops away.
What replaces it is the unvarnished reality of working in this trade: the sleepless nights, the self-doubt, the financial and technical pressure, and the sheer determination required to keep modern vehicles on the road.
Across dozens of interviews at Delphi Academy and Saturday night’s awards, one common thread stood out above the technical skill and business acumen. Almost everyone I spoke to admitted that, at some point, they had questioned whether they were good enough to be there.
Imposter syndrome in the workshop
In an industry that traditionally prizes quiet resilience, it is easy to assume that top-performing technicians and award-winning garage owners never second-guess themselves. The reality is quite the opposite.
Steve Smith, a former champion, long-standing judge and one of the sharpest diagnostic minds in the country, admitted that walking up to each competition task used to send his adrenaline through the roof.
Meanwhile, Richard Maitland Price of Shaws Service Station in North Wales told me he had spent years avoiding industry competitions altogether because he genuinely doubted he belonged in the same room as the sector’s best.
Yet after pacing the corridor at Delphi Academy, he delivered his presentation with his head held high, and went on to lift the Multi-Site Top Garage crown on Saturday night. As he put it beforehand: “Win or lose, forever now, I am a Top Garage finalist.”
Then there was John Fountain. Walking into the workshop at Delphi Academy, he muttered under his breath: “Why on earth do I keep doing this to myself?”
Later, he explained what drove him. When he left school 40 years ago, his teachers told him he was stupid and would never amount to anything.
Four decades later, he was standing in front of complex modern vehicle systems, testing himself against the sharpest minds in the trade—not for silverware, but to prove something to himself.
Resisting the “ricochet bullet” trap
That human pressure also reveals a critical technical lesson for every busy workshop on a Monday morning.
One of the standout diagnostic challenges from last year’s finals involved a Toyota Mirai hydrogen fuel cell vehicle.
Watching finalists enter the bay and spot a hydrogen powertrain produced an audible intake of breath. The actual fault? A familiar 16-amp parasitic battery drain caused by a stuck heated rear screen relay.
It was a masterclass in diagnostic assessment. The test wasn’t designed to catch technicians out on exotic fuel-cell theory; it was a test of process, discipline and resisting the urge to overcomplicate a fault.
David Weston, who won Top Technician last year after pursuing the title for 13 years, summed up what happens when pressure takes over in the bay. He called it becoming a “ricochet bullet”, bouncing from one suspected component to another, firing diagnostic shots in every direction and hoping something sticks.
His advice applies equally to a competition final and a backed-up workshop schedule: stop, breathe, trust your foundational knowledge and follow the test plan.
Behind the balance sheet
While technicians face intense scrutiny on the workshop floor, independent garage owners face an equally unforgiving examination behind closed doors.
Sitting in front of an judging panel to defend your profit margins, staff retention, training culture and business model in a matter of minutes is a world away from managing day-to-day customer service.
As Ross Martin from Repair My Car noted, five-star Google reviews are great, but independent peer scrutiny is the only real way to benchmark how a workshop measures up against the very best.
Yet behind the spreadsheets and business plans sits a sacrifice customers rarely see.
Betta from JGG Automotive spoke candidly about watching her husband, David, pour his life into building their business—the long hours, the sleepless nights and the personal toll of putting your name above the door.
She insisted the recognition did not belong solely to them. “Reaching this final isn’t just about us,” she said. “It belongs to the technicians and service advisors. They aren’t just part of the business, they are the business.”
Crushing outdated apprentice stereotypes
If there is one area where the trade still battles an outdated image, it is recruitment.
For too long, vehicle maintenance has been unfairly dismissed by careers advisers and parents as a second-rate option defined by dirty overalls, sweeping floors and passing someone a 10mm socket.
Watching Colin Denton and the judging team put the Top Apprentice finalists through variable resistor circuits, chassis faults and modern electrical architectures under strict exam conditions puts that stereotype to bed. There are no shortcuts and no hand-holding, just logical thinking and genuine engineering.
Speaking with two-time finalist Katie Bowes, who originally went to Bath to study musical theatre before discovering automotive engineering, highlighted exactly the kind of talent our sector can attract when we get the message right.
Katie spoke openly about how her ADHD thrives on the structured problem-solving of diagnostics, alongside her ambition to build workshops where female motorists feel respected and understood.
An independent benchmark
Competitions like the Top Awards matter not because they hand out trophies, but because they provide an independent benchmark of excellence in a sector evolving at breakneck speed.
Every finalist who stepped into Delphi Academy this year proved that behind every sharp diagnostic technician, resilient garage owner and promising apprentice is someone who has had to push past self-doubt to raise their own standards.
Whether they walked away with an award on Saturday night or not, that willingness to put their skills and businesses on the line is what keeps this trade moving forward.
