Let’s talk about the consumer press, again. This week, Auto Express dropped a headline designed to grab attention and drive clicks: ‘Local garage doomed: spiraling costs and mobile repairs threaten small car service‘.

It is exactly the kind of doom-and-gloom narrative that makes for a dramatic read over a Sunday coffee. But for those of us actually standing on the workshop floor, managing staff, and keeping the UK’s ageing fleet safely on the roads, it is not just factually wrong, it is insulting to the hardest-working sector in the automotive industry.

The mainstream media has a long history of completely misunderstanding the DNA of the independent automotive aftermarket, and this latest headline is no exception.

Yes, the physical and financial realities of running a workshop are tougher than ever. Nobody in the trade is denying that overheads are biting. Energy bills have skyrocketed, the cost of parts fluctuates daily, and the investment required to train technicians on high-voltage and alternative powertrains is significant.

But to look at a tightening economy and assume the independent sector is simply going to roll over and die shows a fundamental ignorance of how this industry operates.

Related: Northern Ireland workshop turns Garage Hive data into £500k growth in just one year

Independent garages are not dying; they are getting smarter. The workshops that are thriving today have stopped racing to the bottom with discounted MOTs. They are charging properly for their diagnostic expertise, they are investing in the hybrid and EV training that main dealers thought they had cornered, and they are leveraging the exact high-margin, complex work that keeps revenue flowing.

Then there is the supposed “threat” of mobile repairs. The consumer press looks at app-based mechanics and main dealer mobile service vans and assumes the traditional workshop is obsolete. But let’s inject some workshop reality into this narrative.

A mobile technician is fantastic for a driveway oil drop or a wiper blade swap. But a man in a van cannot perform a precision four-wheel alignment. They cannot calibrate a complex ADAS system on a wet gravel driveway. And they certainly aren’t equipped to safely drop a high-voltage EV battery or handle the emerging 700-bar hydrogen systems we are already seeing enter the market.

Mobile vans are a convenience play, but they are absolutely no substitute for the heavy lifting, advanced diagnostics, and comprehensive repair capabilities of a fully equipped independent workshop. But let’s not forget, independent garages can go mobile too – just look at Cleevely EV Mobile.

Related: Carly backtracks on £110 “rip-off repair” myth

What publications like Auto Express consistently fail to measure is the ultimate currency of the aftermarket: trust.

When a driver is hit with an aggressive dashboard warning light or a £2,000 repair quote from a franchised dealer, they do not turn to a corporate mobile unit or an anonymous app. They turn to the local independent expert they know by name. They turn to the workshop that has kept their family’s vehicles safely on the road for the last decade without ripping them off.

The local independent garage is not doomed. It is evolving. The tools on the bench are changing, the vehicles on the ramps are changing, and the business models are tightening up to match the times. But as long as complex vehicles need fixing, the local workshop will remain the unbreakable backbone of the UK automotive ecosystem.

The analysts and boardrooms have had their say, now it’s time for yours. How is business on the shop floor lately? Are independent garages really doomed, or are you seeing more opportunity out there than ever? Share your comments below.